Expert insight
November 18, 2026
As Congress begins to consider the next generation of retirement savings legislation, Vanguard is advocating for policy changes that could help millions of Americans build greater financial security. Drawing on extensive client, industry, academic, and government data, Vanguard researchers have identified key friction points in the U.S. private retirement system—from gaps in automatic enrollment coverage, to challenges when workers change jobs, to the complexity faced by retirees who need to convert accumulated savings to dependable income.
In this Q&A, Fiona Greig, global head of Policy and Research, and Ben Barasky, head of U.S. Advocacy, discuss what the data reveal about where the retirement system falls short and how policy solutions could create better outcomes for investors.
Greig: I was struck by how many people still aren’t in employer plans with automatic enrollment. It’s a major focus at Vanguard—61% of the plans we administer automatically enroll their participants. Nationally, that figure is only 42%.1 Another 16.6 million workers could benefit from automatic enrollment, so the opportunity is significant.
I was also surprised by the cumulative impact of what I’d call “fine print” in plan design. Many people switch jobs every year, and when you add up all the little frictions—low default saving rates, lack of immediate eligibility, vesting requirements—there are just so many ways people’s savings journeys lose momentum with every job change. We knew the fine print mattered, but the magnitude of how many people were affected is striking.
Barasky: Retirement savings policy remains one of the last bastions of bipartisan agreement in Washington, D.C. We saw it with the SECURE Act and SECURE 2.0 Act, and we’re optimistic that will continue. That said, congressional attention is spread across many priorities. It’s somewhat peculiar that the first SECURE acts passed just three years apart. Before that, you’d have to go back to the Pension Protection Act in 2006 for the last truly meaningful bill. We think Congress will start working on SECURE 3.0 in earnest, but it could be a few years before something moves from introduction to enactment.
Greig: We have these two vehicles for retirement savings—defined contribution plans and IRAs—and we’ve designed all these automatic features in DC plans that help get people into default investment alternatives. There’s no reason we shouldn’t be able to automatically invest contributions and rollovers into IRAs as well.
What’s surprising is seeing so much cash in accounts dedicated for retirement, especially among those with lower balances and younger investors. These are the people with the longest investment horizons who ought to be thinking about higher equity allocations. We believe that qualified default investments could help young people save almost $60,000 more by retirement age by avoiding cash drag.
Barasky: This body of research spans both wholly new ideas and areas where we’re building upon existing policy that works. It can be easier to enact something when an idea is already on the books and you’re just adjusting the dial.
For example, automatic enrollment isn’t new—SECURE 2.0 required it for new plans, and Vanguard’s data shows its immense impact versus voluntary enrollment. Applying that to all plans will benefit a broad range of people. That’s building on proven policy.
Ideas like a retirement income paycheck or bringing default investments to IRAs are newer concepts. We’ll need to help policymakers and investors understand why we’re advocating for these changes and how they’ll help people. That’s why we quantify the impact on an individual investor basis and share the background on why these policies would help them.
Greig: Sure. Many retirees rely on Social Security for five to 10 years before IRS rules require them to start taking minimum distributions from their IRAs and employer-sponsored retirement plans at 73. Required minimum distributions are generally taxable, and they can bump people into higher tax brackets.
The lifetime tax obligations are lower if you smooth income across all those years, taking some distributions from retirement accounts in your 60s and early 70s, before they become required. That approach limits the income step-up when RMDs begin. It also aligns better with spending patterns. National survey data shows that early retirees spend a lot in the so-called go-go years, but then spending naturally declines in later retirement as people’s capacity to spend decreases. The current behavior pattern loads spending at the wrong phase of retirement.
Barasky: Vanguard’s mission is to take a stand for all investors, to treat them fairly, and to give them the best chance for investment success. Our policy advocacy is one way we take a stand. We use the power of our data to demonstrate how policies like automatic enrollment for all plans could benefit savers over their lifetime. And we do it on a nonpartisan basis, reflective of our 50 million individual investors.
There may be providers who have concerns about the cost of these ideas or what they might mean to their business model and fee structures. The through line in our advocacy work is not how a policy affects Vanguard, but how it affects the end investor. That’s the privilege of our mission.
Editor’s note: Taken together, Vanguard’s six ideas offer policymakers a path to strengthen the retirement system across the full retirement journey. Explore the full paper with our recommendations and research to learn more.
1 Sources: How America Saves (Vanguard, 2026), for the share of Vanguard plans with automatic enrollment; Using Large Language Models to Measure U.S. Retirement Plan Design at Scale: Methods and Evidence (2026 working paper by Taha Choukhmane, John Dedyo, Cormac O’Dea, and Lawrence D. W. Schmidt), for the national figure.
Notes:
All investing is subject to risk, including possible loss of principal.
We recommend you consult a tax and/or legal advisor about your individual situation.
Contributors

Ben Barasky